When Karen Imhoff finds a beaten man lying unconscious by the road in her Amish community, she doesn't hesitate to help. "John Doe" needs a place to stay while he regains his memory, and she has a room to rent. The handsome Englisher proves invaluable around the family farm, yet his presence wreaks havoc with her emotions. Karen can't fall for an outsider who doesn't know his own identity. But as Christmas draws closer, the simple grace of this life and this woman could inspire John to make Karen's dreams come true.